A Tee Shirt Is Just a Tee Shirt, Right?

First of all, I want to acknowledge those parents who continue to be amazing advocates for their young adopted children. I know you love them, as my family loves me. That’s why I am writing this post.

Yesterday, on Facebook, there was a fundraising tee shirt posted for Ethiopian adoptions. There were a lot of comments about it, some in support of the shirt and many criticizing it. The post isn’t there any more. I don’t know why it was deleted.

I would have written my comment on the original post, but since it is gone now, I decided to speak out about it.

The shirt said “Adopt Ethiopia,” and  “Love makes a family…changes a life.”

I find a few things problematic about these tee shirts for Ethiopian adoptions. One is the perception that children need to be saved or rescued. This approach is often used for African adoptions and let me tell you: it sickens me. When white adoptive parents fundraise with these shirts, it unfortunately echoes and perpetuates the white savior complex. This shirt is meant for the adoptive parent to wear. It is difficult when seeing this shirt to avoid the immediate conclusion that prospective parents are romantically reaching out to the farthest corners of the globe to save a desperately lost and innocent child, and should be congratulated.

Adoption does change a lot of lives. Too often, people forget that this also means the first/birth families, who have to lose their child for adoption to happen. Too many “orphans” turn out not to be orphans.

As an adoptee who has been in reunion for seven years with my birth family, I consider my perspective to be representative of my first family. I find this shirt offensive because it dismisses the losses that first families go through when a child is placed for adoption.

Although adoption is a gain for adoptive families, it’s a loss both for the first families and the children. We need to do a better job of acknowledging that. Believe me, I understand there are children who still need homes, and there is no question that all children deserve safe and loving families. But with all the fraud and corruption that’s going on in Ethiopia, why are parents still willing to do fundraisers for adoption? We actually need to be fundraising for more resources that work to make adoption more transparent and ethical. We also need fundraisers that promote family reunification and preservation, because that would help many more children at a lot less cost.

Last, but not least, the quote on the shirt suggests that love conquers all, which is a huge misconception that far too many families believe, or at least want to believe. It also suggests that first families didn’t love their children enough. It dismisses the rejection many adoptees feel, from their first families and from their country of origin. I also believe this shirt supports the profitable industry of adoption (I’m sure many agencies would love it,).

I’ve been critical in my comment here, and some of you might view it as anti-adoption, or dismiss me as an unhappy, even angry adoptee. I hope you will view it as pro-ethical standards. I love my adoptive family, and I love my Ethiopian family. The adoption community needs to be more compassionate about first families, which include not just birth parents but also grandparents, aunts, uncles, siblings, and more. Please educate yourselves. Talk to other adult adoptees, especially those who have searched and/or reunited with their first families. Many adoptive parents active in Facebook groups have young children, but I hope you reach out to adult adoptees that have walked the walk—and lived the talk.

IMG_7096

Advertisements

15 thoughts on “A Tee Shirt Is Just a Tee Shirt, Right?

  1. Interesting read – great to have the perspective of an adoptee! After all, shouldn’t adoption be all about the children/people adopted!

    Very well written, I hope people will challenged by your perspective, particularly because it did NOT come from an angry place! 🙂

    Liked by 2 people

  2. Thank you for sharing your unique perspective. As a parent working through the Ethiopian adoption process I agree we need to focus on transparency, family preservation, and reunification. And to that end we sponsor children through organizations that focus on keeping families together. My thought is this, what about all the kids without homes, in the meantime. Should we allow them to go without families? For those of us in this expensive process fundraising has been necessary, especially when we leave corrupt agencies to work with better more transparent ones. And you’re right, it’s not about me being Caucasian and “saving” a kid. It’s about our family saying we have room in our hearts and in our home for someone who needs it.

    Like

      1. Thank you for recommending these organizations–I look forward to checking them out. (I really appreciate your post too).

        Like

      2. I reviewed the organizations you suggested and they all three seem like good programs. Based on what some of them are doing and the fact that you suggest supporting them you obviously have no problem with children in need being adopted. So is it the idea of people outside their culture and country adopting them that seems offensive?

        Like

  3. I didn’t understand the truth of your perspective until well after we adopted our son (not from Ethiopia, from India). Seeing his struggle-in part because he was in an orphanage, in part from the deep pain at what he feels as being abandoned-I wish that the culture of adoption here would change from adoption first to keeping families together and then in cases where that just isn’t possible…THEN and only then move to adoption. But let’s be real….adoption brings select few big bucks. And families are the ones that suffer. First families, adoptees, and even the adoptive parents when the reality of the weight of responsibility they now carry settles in. So much needs to change. Unfortunately that voice is not a welcome one at this time. Thank you for your thoughts. I only pray that I can do the best I can to love and affirm my child in a way that he can grow in confidence in who he is, and I pray that someday he can also find healing in reunification.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s